The Last of Us is n’t just about outlive the Revelation of Saint John the Divine , it ’s about how far you ’ll go to keep the people you love from slip through your finger . By the remnant of season 1 , Joel ’s faced with the worst decision of his life , and the choice he makes changes everything . To pull through Ellie , he take down the Fireflies , hoi polloi who were endeavor to make a cure , and then lies to her . But is that why Joel lied to Ellie ?
time of year 2 kick off with that lie hang over everything . And the aftermath of Joel ’s selection is a slow burn of regret , guilt feelings , and war . It ’s like this fog that just wo n’t clear . Let us plunk into why he did what he did and how the lie twist everything between them .
What did Joel do at the Hospital?
At the end ofThe Last of Usseason 1 , Joel and Ellie at long last get together the Fireflies , believing their long journeying to be over . But Joel learns that to create a therapeutic from Ellie ’s resistance to theCordyceps fungus , the Fireflies would need to surgically off Ellie ’s brain to extract the fungal growth creditworthy for her resistance , kill her in the outgrowth . The Fireflies construe this sacrifice as the last hope for humanity ’s survival .
However , for Joel , this mean lose Ellie . Having already experience the heartbreak of lose his daughter , Sarah , he could n’t let his ‘ other ’ daughter take on the same end . So , he storms the Firefly infirmary , killing anyone in his route . He kills doctor , nanny , soldiers , and Dr. Jerry Anderson , the surgeon who was mean to perform the surgery . After the mass murder , Joel bequeath with Ellie .
When Ellie regains cognisance , Joel lie to her . He tells her that the Fireflies found other immune people but could n’t create a cure and that the hospital was assault by raiders , ram them to escape . Ellie does n’t seem to believe his narrative .
Pedro Pascal as Joel and Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last of Us (Image via HBO Max)
Why Did Joel Lie to Ellie?
Joel is a man flawed in more ways than one . He was never trying to be a poor boy or save the earth . In the post - apocalyptic the pits he called rest home , survival of the fittest was all that mattered . Then he met Ellie , and his animation receive meaning . Through the infliction , departure , and violence they endure over their journey , Joel began seeing her as a girl . The mission to deliver her to the Fireflies slowly lost meaning . What mattered now was keeping her good . Could any of us really walk away from someone we love that deeply ?
Letting a child break for the Leslie Townes Hope of a curative that was n’t even guaranteed to body of work would take a unlike kind of person . Joel was n’t that kind of man . He did what many of us might have done in his place . But he also knew the gravity of that decision . Deep down , he understood that what he did was inexcusable . If Ellie ever teach the Sojourner Truth , it could destroy her . Not just their hamper , but her common sense of aim . cognise that humanity ’s one chance at a cure died with her survival would be a burden too heavy for her to carry . Ellie is shown as a strong and tough missy . Joel knew she would have founder her life to save humanity .
So Joel keep the accuracy hidden , not just to protect himself , but to protect Ellie from the pain . The lie was n’t tell out of venom , but out of love . It was the ultimate perfidy and the ultimate forfeit wrap into one . We can judge him all we want , but faced with the same choice , any of us could have done precisely what he did . It was the conclusion taken by a father , and what he thought would be the good for his girl .
Pedro Pascal as Joel and Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last of Us (Image via HBO Max)
Ellie Doesn’t Believe Joel’s Lie
Even in that final scene of season 1 , Ellie ’s aspect enjoin it all . She does n’t conceive him . Not fully . She asks him if everything he say about the Fireflies is true . Joel looks her in the center and says , “ I swear . ” Ellie break , then says , “ Okay . ” But it is not acceptance . It is capitulation . She knows that Joel did something awful that he can not reveal to her , and she is better off without knowing . It was a powerful moment that changed the bond between them always .
Ellie does n’t advertise Joel in that minute , but the incertitude hover . And as sentence passes in season 2 , the cracks in their relationship only originate wider . There are no veracious answers as to whether what Joel did was right or awry ; either way , he made his choice , and now the consequence of that selection will obsess him and Ellie in season 2 .
TLoU S2E5: Finally, Spores Are Here Bring Show Closer to…
MonsterVerse Watch Order Guide: Watch Godzilla and Kong Movies in…
Squid Game S3 Teaser Trailer Breakdown: Gi-hun’s Returns with even…
TLoU S2E4: Truce Between Seraphites (Scars) and WLF (Wolves) Explained
The Last of Us S2E4: Who Are Isaac, Hanrahan, and…
The Last of Us Season 2 Episode 4: Release Date,…
Marvel’s Thunderbolts: Both Post-Credits Scenes Explained
The Last of Us Season 2: Who Is Seraphites (Scars)…
Now You See Me 3 – Does the Heart Diamond…
The Last of Us Season 2 Episode 3: 8 Ways…
Pedro Pascal as Joel and Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last of Us (Image via HBO Max)
Pedro Pascal as Joel and Bella Ramsey as Ellie in The Last of Us (Image via HBO Max)
