If you are looking for a privacy - focused e-mail service of process , there are 2 e-mail providers at the top of the inclination – ProtonMail and Tutanota . For starters , both Tutanota and ProtonMail areopen - source , free up to a limit , and support end - to - conclusion encoding . Now if that makes things puzzling for you , here ’s a head - to - pass elaborated comparison of Tutanota vs ProtonMail .
ProtonMail vs Tutanota
1. Interface/Ease of Use
Let ’s start up with the interface of these apps and the ease of usage . Foremost , allow ’s see the mobile apps .
If you compare the nomadic port of ProtonMail and Tutanota side - by - side , I detect ProtonMail to be minimal and square . The home page of the app is your default inbox . On the top - left , you have the ground beef flair card which lets you flip between draft , send an electronic mail , access tangency , etc . The compose email Sir Frederick Handley Page is a traditional one where you have to enter the sender ’s e - postal service , open , and substance . Additionally , ProtonMail bring home the bacon you the lock icon to password - encrypt the email .
Moreover , if you are coming from Gmail orInbox , you will rule swipe gestures ready to hand . you may filch right to score a post as register and result to edit it . These gestures can be modified in the ProtonMail configurations .
Tutanota , on the other hand , is more optimized for mobile devices . You have a bottom piloting bar to switch between search , contacts , and calendar . The hamburger computer menu does n’t provide many selection unless you create your own folders . Similar to ProtonMail , you have swipe motion . you’re able to correct - swipe to archive an e-mail and left-hand - swipe to delete it .
Only Tutanota has a dark mode and feel more comfortable to utilize on a mobile twist .
The web app of both Tutanota and ProtonMail is similar to the mobile versions . Tutanota does offer desktop apps for Windows , macOS , and Linux . On the other hand , ProtonMail does n’t have commit desktop apps .
2. Security and Encryption
Both ProtonMail and Tutanota provide end - to - oddment encryption . This is the highlight feature of these electronic mail services which describe them from ordinary email services like Outlook , Gmail , etc .
In display case you do n’t know , end - to - end encoding aka . E2EE guarantee that substance are encipher on your system when you send an email . in the end , it ’s decrypted on the liquidator ’s twist when they open and translate the e-mail . In between , the troupe ’s server or anyone can not read the message because they do n’t be intimate how to decrypt it . The key used for encoding and decipherment of the message stay on the sender and pass catcher ’s gadget topically .
Coming to trifle , both the email services supply 2 type of E2EE . For instance , if the receiver does n’t use ProtonMail or Tutanota , the service use symmetric E2EE . In that case , along with the email you would also have to divvy up the word to interpret the email . Now , in case , the pass catcher uses ProtonMail or Tutanota just like you , the services use asymmetric encryption . In this case , your email word would be the decipherment samara and you do n’t require to partake it along with the e-mail .
Having say that , these high-pitched levels of encoding come at a cost . If you forget your password , both ProtonMail and Tutanota can not recover your mailbox . This is for your own base hit though as they ca n’t get at your emails either .
In term of algorithm , ProtonMail uses OpenPGP for asymmetrical encryption . If the liquidator is a non - ProtonMail user , it apply AES-256 for symmetric encryption . On the other handwriting , Tutanota utilise AES-128 for symmetric encryption . If the receiver is a non - Tutanota substance abuser , Tutanota utilize AES-128 , RSA-2048 to encrypt e-mail .
Tutanota provides a high grade of encryption where it also code your electronic mail subject line along with the message . ProtonMail does n’t cypher your e-mail depicted object agate line but only the soundbox .
3. Business Model
The most overlooked thing while considering a privacy choice is the occupation example . The business theoretical account decides the whole guidance of the company and the ware .
If there is no product , you are the mathematical product .
In terms of placement , both ProtonMail and Tutanota are located in Europe and fall under GDPR . ProtonMail is situate in Switzerland whereas Tutanota is located in Germany .
4. What Data Is Collected
Now , apart from encoding , the second most important thing when it come to privacy - focused apps is datum collection . Security feature are upright but it ’s equally important to know what datum they are collecting .
first , both serve collect your IP address once you sign - up . This IP address is required to hold on spam and misuse of the services . When you send an email , the services do hive away the email destination of both the sender and receiver .
In terms of letter box log , Tutanota deletes these logs in 7 days whereas ProtonMail tends to keep it a bit longer . It hive away the information until you choose to delete your invoice . However , these IP addresses and e-mail log are anonymized .
5. Features
In terminus of additional feature , there ’s not much to expect from both other than secrecy and security . That ’s their USP . ProtonMail supply you integrated contact and groups within the email app . You do n’t observe an integrated calendar though . However , you could separately downloadProtonCalendarwhich is in genus Beta as of now . ProtonMail also supports melt e - mails which are kind of nerveless and work like disappearing messages .
On the other handwriting , Tutanota does proffer an end - to - end code Calendar along with a mailbox but misses out on disappearing e-mail .
In case you usethird - political party email clients , you ’d be happy to know that ProtonMail integrates with third - company email clients via ProtonMail Bridge . ProtonBridge manages the encryption and decoding of the mail with third - party Service . However , this option is only usable for premium substance abuser .
Tutanota , as of now , does n’t provide you the selection to use it via a third - party email customer .
6. Pricing
basically , both ProtonMail and Tutanota are liberal . On the costless interpretation , both services wo n’t cater you customs duty domain names which is the trend with innocent e-mail services . Free account of ProtonMail and Tutanota will get you 400 MB to 1 GB of free blank respectively .
If you want to promote , ProtonMail starts at $ 5 / calendar month whereas Tutanota set off at $ 1.4 / calendar month . Tutanota is far cheap in terms of pricing but provide lower storage at 1 GB compare to 5 GB on ProtonMail . If you do n’t deal with lots of spiritualist or presentations , Tutanota seems the more sensible deal .
One of the high spot of the ProtonMail subscription is that you could upgrade storage by 1 GB at a time . If you are an soul , this option really helps save a lot of money rather than the doctor storage options .
ProtonMail or Tutanota: What Should You Choose
With the choice between Tutanota vs ProtonMail , I would favour ProtonMail due to more phone number of drug user on the servicing . This way , you do n’t have to exchange an additional password whenever you air an electronic mail . Moreover , if you employ ProtonMail ’s other services likefree VPN , the cost would be much lower .
Also Read:6 Best 2FA Apps and Security Key Devices to lumber in Securely Anywhere
